I know for certain that it is a damn sight faster to get things done if you just do it and then ask for forgiveness afterwards.
Here is my dilemma and objective. I spent last evening rereading all of JDales ‘New Tables’ thread to try and come back up to speed with RMU. The motivation is to try and put together a set of rules I am happy with that use the rules as close to what will be in the final released game as possible.
The cornerstone will be the No Profession profession as that is RAW. There are lots of things that I want to house rule and the problem is do you house rule and have a better game or do you play RAW and have a viable play test?
I am coming down on the side of house rules. ICE have had years of play test feedback and the impression I get now is that the rules are pretty much set. Even with house rules I would not be changing EVERYTHING so all that remains unchanged will be viable playtest feedback.
What I would like to do is play a game and then publish my impressions here on the blog. Now that is very dodgy considering the NDA but if I do not publish the rules as written, which is what I think the NDA is there to prevent, then I feel morally comfortable with that.
I would then want some players who are happy for the game to be publicly discussed although obviously they would not be discussed, just their characters and what happened in the game world.
The blogs would then cover character creation, the selection of the house rules and the official optional rules and how the game sessions played out.
I would run the game as a PBP so that I had a written record that I could then review for the blogs.
This blog exists in part to promote RM in all its forms so publicly promoting RMU has to be part of its remit surely?
My Christmas Day post will be the list of options and house rules that I intend to use, these will be up for discussion so anyone else that is playing RMU can chip in their own suggestions as to anything they think I will regret.
2 thoughts on “Is it better to beg forgiveness or ask for permission?”
Can’t answer the initial question, really, but given the fact that much of the beta rules have been discussed – and pilloried – by Tim Dugger on his (long-inactive but still available site), that horse has, to some extent bolted. At least you’ll offer constructive criticism rather than working off multiple grudges.
You will, however, have to walk a mighty fine line…
I’m happy to contribute to the PbP if you don’t mind time zone issues from down here in New Zealand.
Looking forward to it!