With every new product Terry Amthor publishes, the world of Kulthea grows larger and more detailed, but it’s been quite a while since an updated version of the SW Master Atlas was produced. In truth, there has been a tremendous amount of world building material generated, but it’s been scattered among the various SW supplements over the last 30 years.
In general, a setting’s “Master Atlas” should contain the overview and broad strokes of the world—the foundation that sets the table for all other material. It should differentiate between “world spanning”, “universal” and “ubiquitous” and material that is regional in nature. Using that very basic definition you could argue that the Loremasters and Navigators are Master Atlas material while the Eight Orders of the Emerian Empire are not. Certainly, some of this is arbitrary, but if a new Master Atlas was planned, what should be included? Part of it is consolidating this “world material” from existing products and the other is filling in the blanks—new material that fleshes out the world, answers important questions or establishes setting specific material that might be different than general Rolemaster rules. (see the blog here)
IIRC, Rolemaster Companion I was generated from the “Red Book”—a notebook filled with optional material used in the early days by key ICE employees and playtesters. The material was cleaned up and made into Companion. We have our own version of the “Red Book”—our own Master Atlas that consolidates all “world material” into the existing MA4 text (converted in editable Word format). We went through each product, starting with the Iron Wind, and added any pertinent material: languages, creatures, Loremasters, artifacts, key persons etc. When a new product comes out, we go through it and do the same thing; our current MA stands at 320 pages without the numbered timeline and without fauna/flora. With fauna/flora our comprehensive MA would be well over 500 pages without artwork and graphics. Is that too large for todays consumers?
Some of that (100+ pages) is our own material—some of it posted up on the Misc SW Files. What is the origin of Elves? What happened to the Earthwardens? Where did the Dragonlords come from? What is the origina and the genesis of the various monsters/creatures? What are the reasons behind “magical” alloys? What is the background behind the lack of chemical processes in SW? We wrote it out of necessity, much of it years ago when it wasn’t clear if SW would continue. I think we came up with some good answers to many of these questions—but ultimately may be modified based on new material Terry produces.
Even with all the material we have, plus the material we’ve written I think there are gaps in the Master Atlas. After 4 versions, it’s probably not a priority for Terry to tackle the Master Atlas yet again even as he updates other past regional products. But…if such a product were to materialize, what would you like to see in it? Here are a few of my own:
1. Language etymology. Matt did some work on it and I tried some basic classifications but it would be nice to have a basic “language tree” based on the root languages and sub families to build a framework for future products and establish relationships between cultures for language skills/translations etc.
2. Essence Flow and Foci Map. While I like the idea of not creating permanent Major Flows, they are a key part of the world. Nexus is surrounded by them; Tanara was isolated by them etc. There was a map from an earlier product (Emer in the Atlas Addendum) but I think reintroducing these permanent flows helps fix the Flows as an important physical manifestation of the setting.
3. Setting specific creatures. Much of the flora/fauna of SW is just a duplication of Creatures & Treasures. This feels like shoe horning a generic fantasy framework into a more unique setting. I would prefer to see a broadening of SW specific bestiary: more fusion and bizarre creatures.
4. The Pales. Something I’ve been working on is added material on the Pales: environment, more denizens, realm powers etc. It would be great to have them fleshed out as real places that could be visited or used for travelling. My group is currently in the 2nd Pale and pushed me to build the setting out more for the adventure.
5. Finished SW specific spell lists. Additional spell lists for the Unlife (type specific rather than general) and the other groups detailed in Powers of Light & Darkness.
6. Finalized and consistent rules about the Unlife. Eliminate the “Anti-Essaence” and create framework for channeling (?) the Unlife and corruption rules.
7. Notable world wide holidays and religious celebrations.
8. Simultaneous publication for D20 rulesets.
Just a few of my ideas—anybody have any other ideas for the “definitive” SW Master Atlas?
10 thoughts on “Shadow World Wish List: the definitive Master Atlas.”
The largest, most expensive, supplement I have ever bought is a print on demand one I purchased in the last few years – Ptolus. It’s a 670 page hardback, so yes, I think there is a market. It may not be as large a market as for smaller supplements though. I get the impression that a new Master Atlas may start development after RMU is finished to incorporate the new system. I’ve also stated for a while that I think catering to Pathfinder – and now 5E – would be a good idea. Yes, the bestiary in SWMA4 in particular feels rather generic, but I wonder whether it might be better to have a SW specific bestiary rather than include it in an atlas. There are other background areas (which you’ve mentioned) which I think I’d rather see in it. A new atlas would be a major project though and one which I think would have to be a team effort to a degree.
I think 80% is done if you collate all of Terry’s world material. Filling in the blanks and reformatting for RMU/DD/PF seems fairly simple in terms of leveraging content to demand?
You’ve created content–any specifics you think should be included in a World Atlas?
It’s hard to say. I have a tendency to go into too much detail than would probably be suitable for a broad overview. There are groups – the Alliance, Loremasters, Navigators and Raven Queen – that could do with more information on them. The same with many of the continents. However, most of these could do with specific supplements as well.
The timeline is also a bit tricky. It’s important, but it gets changed every time Terry writes a new supplement. I have thought that perhaps the timeline in a PDF which gets updated every new release might be better than putting it in the Master Atlas, or perhaps only having some in the atlas.
I think anywhere that players have a chance of going to could also do with more fleshing out. More setting-specific items and spells (although some of that could be in Artefacts & Lost Technology).
I’m unsure whether it would be better having one supplement, or several.
The timeline is a good point. Matt and I actually changed it into a narrative form as a detailed overview rather than the year by year format. Then the master narrative would be kept updated via the Nomikos Library project. I should post up the narrative on the RM Forums…
Looks good! I wonder if a timeline like that might be more suited to the Master Atlas, rather than one that keeps altering, and making that into a separate supplement?
Here’s a slightly different idea for a Master Atlas – make it system-agnostic. Then make system-specific supplements for it.
I don’t know how easy or popular such an idea would be though.
I would really support this idea and for ICE there are licensing opportunities to allow other systems to produce system specific supplements for closed systems.
Might be interesting to make a post in the forums to see if others, including terry, chip in.
I would like to see the languages fleshed out a bit and cleaned up. There seemed to be a bit of inconsistency (maybe it was just me) between the languages in the Master Atlas and in the recently published player guide.