RMU: Wargamification of Rolemaster?

A comment back in September resonated with me and I jotted it down to blog about at a later date. Well here we are! I thought this was well stated, or touched upon some of my own thoughts (bold emphasis mine):

To me all of these defensive values are too gamist (in GNS terms). Feels very tactical. Ends up feeling very much like GURPS combat, actually (which, I guess, these changes were inspired by). I loved how RM2 abstracted all that into pouring a part of your OB into parry (I limit that to 50% towards bigger weapons and animal attacks, though -> ie dodge). Made it easy for non gamers to play. The cool thing in RM is that the tables do the „believability“ heavy lifting and the game is rather rules light and easy to run (even SS/FRP is pretty rules light at the table, mainly the skill system is a complex broken mess). I have the feeling that RMU is quickly becoming quite rules heavy, almost D&D 3E levels of complexity with ChaCo. Since about 60% of my sessions are with non-gamers (family and work colleagues) it makes it hard to use RMU.

To put this in context, this was a part of an ongoing discussion around DB and newer RMU mechanisms that can add to a player defense: footwork, running, blocking, parrying, dodging etc. I’ll admit that I only have the rudiments of the final RMU rules but I will occasionally follow some of the discord threads to get a sense of player feedback and thoughts.

As a long ago player of Squad Leader, I’m fairly conversant in wargaming, or “simulationist battle gaming”. There very purpose of wargame rules it maximize tactical simulation, accuracy and realism through specific and erudite rules. Despite Rolemaster’s mandate of “realism”, it was really the illusion of realism that made it work. It provided minutia in a couple of key areas, but otherwise was just “rules by odds making”. As gamers we are just gamblers assessing risk on a percentile basis.

Benjhomyr summed up his thoughts about some of the RMU rules better than I could but it spoke to me: “values are too gamist (in GNS terms). Feels very tactical“. That is also my impression when reading the RMU threads. To be clear, this is not criticism, but more my ongoing curiosity for the apparent need to pinpoint, measure, assess EVERY aspect of a tactical encounter.

This only reinforces my one major adjustment to the Rolemaster combat process: the division of OB into attack, defend AND attack speed (initiative). For me this solution perfectly encapsulates the original spirit of Rolemaster. It provides an elegant solution to complexity.

I’m sure at some point in the future I’ll be writing material for RMU, but I see that no differently than translating words into another language. My native tongue is Rolemaster 1st Ed. and the peculiarities of RMU rules is just that: a different methodology, another language, to describe the same thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *