Thoughts on Progression Fantasy

I found the blog post above to be timely. There has been some discussion on the discord servers that also tangentially touch upon the progression process of gaming. Generally it’s framed in terms of balance: classes/professions must be “fair and balanced”, encounters must be “fair and balanced” and so forth.

All of these presume the idea that the game world is much like a video game (zones in WoW and Everquest), with increasing levels of difficulty carefully matched to the PC’s levels and abilities. The roleplaying experience has morphed into player delight and “furthering the story”, but without any inherent risk or sacrifice from the player character. Undesirable deaths or critical results can be remediated through fate points. Clearly this is diametrically opposed to the foundational mechanics of RM: player death is almost a certainty.

Players wanting their characters to survive is not exclusive to Rolemaster gamers; but the long chargen process in RM certainly adds to the desire to live beyond an encounter or two! As character build processes have become more complex in other game systems this feeling seems to have spread.

For me their are two mental models that I would challenge.

The first being the story itself. If the story becomes player centric then the loss of a PC can be very difficult. But if the story is the narrative arc itself, the players have a supporting role: they move the story forward to enjoy the world building, the puzzle solving, the learning and the goal achievement.

The second model to reconsider is the intentional or unintentional need for balance and a progression framework. Ostensibly, the original adventure, the dungeon, was progression manifest. Each level down increased in difficulty and challenge. In fact, many early dungeons were literally populated by creature levels matched to the dungeon level. As the group increased in character levels, so too the depth of their exploration. I have a real issue with progression mechanics in game. The world in unknowable, nature is indifferent and encounters can be random or purposeful. But they don’t have to be “fair and balanced”. Players have tools to assess risk and agency to make informed decisions. Groups that assume, or know, that any encounter was carefully designed to fairly match them will act accordingly, trusting the GM for a positive outcome. The true volatility is not through decision making or problem solving, but just the random results of the open ended dice. Those extreme rolls provide the “verisimilitude” of risk, but the encounters themselves are framed into a safe boundary of stat blocks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *